On The Blue Room we recently published Episode 5 of #EvertonBusinessMatters. The subject was Everton- the brand, and the discussion has created a huge amount of comment. I thought therefore I’d expand further on my views.
I suppose most fans of most clubs see their club as unique, and in one respect they’re right as every club is different. However, I’d challenge any English club to demonstrate a brand which is as complex, rich, omnipresent in league football and embedded within the game and community as that of Everton.
Perhaps it’s the competitive nature of club football that very little attention is given to an identity outside of the club itself. But in the context of global marketing (and leverage from currently stronger brands) think for a moment about the position we enjoy. We’re the senior club among 4 of the most recognisable clubs in the world, all in a tiny corner of England. But that tiny corner spawned league football. In the same way industrialisation arose from the County of Lancashire, so did League Football and ultimately the behemoth that is the Premier League. We, of all the founding members, have maintained (apart from two very short periods) our position at the top of the domestic game, and when the circumstances of resource and talent have coincided briefly at the top of the European game as well. That is a huge part of who we are, and what we offer to branding (sponsor) partners.
We’ve achieved so much in the game, and critically advanced the game significantly, usually at the forefront of all developments. The legendary list of Everton “firsts” are a true testament to our status in the game and should, in fact must be, part of our brand.
On the pitch, we have until recent times had periods of significant success which with more fortuitous timings may have created dynasties rather than short periods of glory. Historical events, much more important than football, critically cut short periods of success, two World Wars and of course the banning of English clubs in Europe. Nevertheless, they’re part of our history and as such are part of our branding – they are what makes Everton, Everton.
Apart from great teams we’ve been blessed with great individuals, Dean, Lawton, Sagar, TG Jones, “the Golden Vision”, Alan Ball, Neville Southall, Rooney (briefly) and perhaps even Lukaku – each adding colour to a rich tapestry of individuals, characters and some of the greatest players to ever play the game – all Everton players, all stars in their own right, but crucially, critically part of the fabric of Everton.
Our stadium is part of who we are – the greatest club stadium possibly in the world. Not the biggest, not currently the grandest, but throughout its history at least until the post Taylor Report days right at the top of the club game. First purpose built stadium with 4 stands, first with 4 double decker stands, the Archibald Leitch influence still present today, the semi circles behind the goals, the FIFA World Cup in 1966, the triple decker main stand built in 1970, a genuine cathedral to the religion of football witnessed by more than 74 million spectators who have passed through her turnstiles. That’s richness almost beyond words in branding terms because it tells a story, a story of 125 years of being one of the truly great theatres of the world’s most popular team game.
Yet for all that, having a past is not enough, and as Moshiri said “we’re not a museum, we must win things”. There’s not an Evertonian that would disagree of course and in branding terms this statement is critical. This I believe is our opportunity in branding and therefore commercial terms. We are rich in history (I’d argue the richest), have huge heritage, depth and complexity, yet critically we stand as a huge redevelopment opportunity.
We’re a development opportunity on and off the pitch. Therefore, the message to would-be sponsors is you are partnering a brand that has a rich, deep multi-faceted back story. We’re a club that has moved through the different times of footballing history, and at a time of huge interest in the game globally (albeit with many growth opportunities ahead of us) we’re poised for another period of development and success with all the commercial benefits that arise from it.
That must be the message to sponsors. With our past, our retained status, and now the investment on and off the field we are a unique branding proposition in the most attractive sporting billboard in the world.
We must sell our past because that is what we are, it is the good times and the bad that has made us what we are, and granted us the position we are in. Our position today and the new Moshiri ownership gives us the opportunity to take that platform to new levels of success and visibility in selling our future.
On top of all the brand qualities we offer, uniquely in my opinion, then visibility is the key to generating the largest revenues in the future. Manchester United for example, average 52 million views on global TV per game. In addition, they have over 600 million social media contacts – for a sponsor an absolute dream for which they pay the eye watering sums United benefit from. However, it’s not beyond the bounds of possibility that with the correct marketing and partnering we couldn’t grow to a similar level over the next decade or so.
My point is that yes, we have to create success on the pitch to enjoy similar commercial success, but, and I’d argue this very strongly, we can bridge the current commercial gaps through two factors. One is the richness of our brand and identity. We offer values as an institution that can seldom be found elsewhere in the footballing world. If a brand wishes to invest in football, there are few richer (in content) brands than Everton. The complexity of our past offers multiple brand associations and share values.
The second is the development opportunity, the opportunity to catch and pass our rivals.
I said in the podcast, a football club can be equated to a river, the river is ever present, yet the waters flow and change over time. I truly believe this is how Everton should be viewed and sold to our partners, even though football can be a quick changing sport, the opportunities for partners along the length of the river and in different conditions exist to be exploited.
The right partners are equally important to our brand. I’m a great believer in finding synergies between the host (Everton) and the sponsor. Equally it is important that the portfolio of sponsors see additional value from the association with co-sponsors. This shouldn’t be over looked in the slightest.
The choosing of sponsorship partners is critical, we must seek similar values and ambitions. If we do so both partners benefit together, and when it comes to future contracts we can demonstrate the success of previous relationships and price our participation accordingly.
As we’ve spoken about, we’ve a long way to go about maximising the opportunities ahead of, thus enabling the revenues to make us truly competitive. However, we have the key component in our brand for the reasons given above, all we need now is the enthusiasm and know how from those charged with selling us, to make sure it happens. That, under our current management remains a huge challenge, but (as with the football team) the addition of new, fresh, proven talent is eminently achievable.
We are a fantastic brand, unique in football, and ripe for development and the resulting monetisation for the benefit of the club and partners.
Categories: Everton finances, Uncategorized
Great article mate. Hopefully we have people in place that can create the buy in, so others can see the club for the great and unique opportunity that it is.
Thanks Sarath, with the stadium plans progressing I believe getting the right people into the business to monetarise the brand of Everton is the next critical off field step
Another good read Esk, and as always, the sting is in the tail in terms of you highlighting the issue of the ‘current management’ within the club.
I’ve listened to all the Everton Business Matters podcasts and found them to be not just a set of rambling fans chewing the cud, but a necessary and essential insight into areas of the clubs operations that need serious planning and organisation, not micro-managing, as the future branding and commercial activity of the club is far, far too vital for one person to oversee and drive.
In my (humble and layman’s) opinion, Mr.Moshiri might be well advised to enlist the help of a hand-picked group of business people with worldwide connections and a massive spread of experience, and some maybe not necessarily with first-hand involvement in sport, although that would be a help – to fully know and understand the territory.
In a very simplistic way, I see a couple of key areas to look at and forgive me if this is (blindingly) simple to the point of childish.
Our potential future branding and commercial partners should, wherever possible, be instantly recognisable and known for being blue – blue logos, corporate imagery.
There are enough massive conglomerates out there with blue as their signature colour… Daimler-Benz (Mercedes),Ford, Samsung, PayPal, Gazprom, Dell etc etc etc.
Secondly, branding and commercial partners – as you rightly suggest – should have similar values and interest… nothing but the best… a desire and willingness to be the absolute best in their chosen field, whatever that is.
And thirdly in my simplistic scenario, be acknowledged worldwide and not just limited to one sector or area of the globe.
I said it was a simple, almost childlike in its outlook, but if a dedicated group of professionals took these as minimum ‘standards’ and developed a strategy and worldwide network, then who knows what might be possible.
Such a team of professionals could operate independently of the day-to-day workings of the club, and report directly to Mr.Moshiri so as to quicken the pace of decision making and get things moving.
I look forward to future EBM podcasts.
Excellent comments Andy which I agree with totally.
The brand of Everton is a marketing man or woman’s dream, the commercial and sponsorship opportunities are immense.
We just need someone appropriately qualified and motivated to be given the task to fulfill the potential
A very interesting, and thought-provoking read. I’ve just discovered your site, but am already hooked! I agree completely with what you say. A couple of thoughts occur to me, which I’m going to have to pu down a bit hastily here. First, the brand that is Everton has been so badly managed over the years and decades, it’s almost criminal when you think of the potential that’s there (much of which you refer to). In terms of brand management, we have been for far too long in the shadow of that lot across the park. There are I think interesting parallels with other historically ‘shadowy’ clubs, such as Man City and Athletico Madrid. So my first question is – are there any lessons to be learned for Everton with the successful way in which these two footballing brands have been managed over the last few years? My second question refers to brand values. Again, I agree with you here. I think the club needs to communicate more on this, as we are quite distinctive in this respect (I’m thinking here of initiatives such as Everton in the Community). Personally, I think the club needs to communicate a coherent set of values, which is why I’m disappointed that we’ve gone from a brewer to a betting company as our new shirt sponsor (I see this morning that there is no mention of Everton on Sportpesa’s website, although there are references to Hull City and Southampton – https://www.sportpesa.org – which given that the new shirt is already out, I find absolutely gobsmacking, and perhaps so ‘Everton’…). This is why, although I find AndyC’s comments interesting, I cannot agree with this suggestion that we entertain Gazprom, as they are, in my opinion, an arm of Putin’s soft power abroad, and not a brand whose values we should emulate. I would have more to say about all this, but am in a rush (a family wedding today). But I just wanted to share with you my ‘gut reaction’ to your – very interesting – post. I look forward very much to reading your other posts, here and elsewhere (especially your piece on Usmanov on Futbolgrad). By the way, I’m a lifelong blue, currently living in exile in France, where for may sins I teach marketing and brand management, and Russian Studies. Nil Satis Nisi Optimism!
Great article. Our rich history, changes for the good on the pitch, new, stadium on the horizon, we are a branding dream and hopefully the club will realise this and get someone who can take our brand forward to future partners.