The Esk


Independent analysis of football's money, owners and rules

Tracker: AM Best cuts A-CAP’s insurers to C- after the Oaktree recapitalisation collapses

CWTE

3 minutes

The Football Capital Tracker · Event date: 11 November 2026 · Event type: Distress or enforcement · Last updated: 18 November 2026

What happened

On 11 November 2026 AM Best downgraded the two rated insurers of A-CAP (Advantage Capital Holdings, ultimately owned by Kenneth King). Atlantic Coast Life and Sentinel Security Life were cut from C+ to C- (Weak), with issuer credit ratings cut from b- to ccc-. Both remain under review with negative implications (AM Best release).

AM Best attributes the downgrade to the termination of A-CAP’s March 2026 master transaction agreement with Oaktree, the central plank of A-CAP’s recapitalisation. Under that agreement Oaktree was to take control of Atlantic Coast Life and fund a surplus note supporting Sentinel. AM Best now assesses the insurers’ balance sheet strength as very weak. It notes that A-CAP is in discussions with another possible capital provider, but names none.

This is the third downgrade in under ten months, from B++ in January 2026. It follows a South Carolina rehabilitation petition against Atlantic Coast Life (15 September 2026), the suspension of its Florida licence (30 September 2026) and a Virginia halt on new business from 1 November 2026.

Football exposure

  • Hertha BSC (2. Bundesliga): A-CAP’s ACM Delegate holds 78.8% of the KGaA’s capital, taken by credit bid in June 2025. The member association keeps voting control under 50+1. The stake is for sale, and Hertha holds a contractual veto over the buyer.
  • Red Star FC (Ligue 2): wholly controlled by A-CAP. The club’s DNCG compliance for 2026/27 rests on financial guarantees from A-CAP for a budget of about €15m.
  • Sevilla FC and Genoa: minority stakes of about 12–14% and about 22% respectively, both being marketed. A-CAP has no governance role at Genoa.
  • 777 Partners: A-CAP-affiliated companies are owed almost US$1.3bn by the 777 debtors in Chapter 11 (Signal National LLC, N.D. Tex., No. 26-90190), all in default.

Why it matters

The clubs A-CAP still holds are now sale assets of a group with no announced, committed source of capital and insurers rated one step above the categories AM Best uses for insurers in supervision or liquidation. Red Star is the most exposed, because its licence depends on A-CAP’s own guarantees. If a rehabilitation order follows in South Carolina, control of these holdings could move to a regulator-appointed rehabilitator rather than A-CAP, depending on which entity legally holds the club equity. That has not been verified from public filings. A forced or discounted sale of Hertha’s stake in 2027 is now the likeliest outcome.

Open questions

  • Who is the unnamed capital provider AM Best refers to, and on what terms?
  • Will the Richland County court grant South Carolina’s rehabilitation petition, or will mediation produce a settlement?
  • Which A-CAP entity legally owns the Hertha, Red Star, Sevilla and Genoa shares, and would they fall within an insurer’s estate?
  • Will the DNCG revisit Red Star’s position if A-CAP’s guarantees weaken further?

Full analysis: A-CAP, 777 Partners and the former 777 football portfolio: the position at November 2026. Dossiers: A-CAP / Leadenhall · 777 Partners.

Back to The Football Capital Tracker.

In this article

Clubs: · · ·
Owners & lenders: · ·
Regulators & bodies:

Paul Quinn

Independent analyst of the finance, ownership, governance and regulation of professional football. Publishes The Esk through CWTE. About · Methodology · Corrections

One response to “Tracker: AM Best cuts A-CAP’s insurers to C- after the Oaktree recapitalisation collapses”

  1. Jerome Shields

    Paul — thanks for this. The tracker format works well for a story moving in steps, and “one step above the categories AM Best uses for insurers in supervision or liquidation” is the line that will matter most to football readers.

    One thing I’d push on, and it goes to your final open question — which A-CAP entity legally owns the Hertha, Red Star, Sevilla and Genoa shares, and whether they’d fall within an insurer’s estate.

    The reason that can’t be answered from public filings isn’t just A-CAP’s own complexity. It’s the 777 Re layer. A-CAP ceded roughly $1.7bn in reserves to 777 Re, the Bermuda reinsurer nominally owned by 777 Partners, whose registration the BMA cancelled in October 2024 for governance and prudent-person failures. But the actual control of 777 Partners — and therefore 777 Re — is disputed. Leadenhall’s complaint alleges A-CAP and Kenneth King were “the puppeteers behind 777 Partners”; King has said publicly that “A-CAP and 777 are not affiliated in any sense.”

    That dispute is why your ownership question is unresolvable on the public record. If Leadenhall is right, the boundary between “A-CAP’s assets” and “777’s assets” is legally indeterminate without discovery — and so is which entity holds the club equity. If King is right, the entities are cleanly separate. Either way, the answer determines whether the football holdings fall inside an insurer’s estate in a South Carolina rehabilitation.

    Worth flagging too that this isn’t only about A-CAP’s balance sheet. The 777 Re opacity is arguably upstream of the downgrades — the reserve-cession structure is part of why balance sheet strength collapsed, why Oaktree’s recapitalisation was the attempted fix, and why its termination in November was so damaging.

    One caution for readers treating this as a purely A-CAP story: there is a documented Russian creditor thread — Oleg Boyko’s Nakula Management lent around $10m to 777’s Sevilla vehicle in 2018 and later sued — but I’ve found no evidence connecting it to Moshiri’s Everton transaction or to the Usmanov–Moshiri line. Separate strand; worth not collapsing them.

    If you’re planning a follow-up, the two documents that would move the ownership question forward are the Nakula/777 London arbitration records and the full 777–Moshiri negotiation correspondence. Neither is public — which I suspect is your point.

    I could not find a connection back to Usmanov which might explain why Moshiri even entertained such company.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Esk Briefing

One email a week: every new report with its key findings. Free, no advertising, unsubscribe at any time.