Paul Quinn, CWTE Limited | 19 November 2026
Credit: Financial Times
This analysis responds to reporting by the Financial Times, published on 19 November 2026: Apollo scraps planned $2bn loan to Man City owner after rule breaches. The FT broke the story, citing people familiar with the matter. Every fact about the loan negotiation is the FT’s, and readers should go to the original.
Everything else (the systemic interpretation, the figures marked as calculated, and the recommendations) is my own and draws on my published work on private credit, solvency and systemic risk in football. Where this piece relies on a fact first reported by the FT, it says so.
Summary
Apollo Global Management, one of the two private credit houses that dominate large-ticket football lending, walked away from a $2bn loan to City Football Group (CFG) at the final stage of negotiation. The FT links the decision directly to the independent Commission’s September finding that Manchester City inflated its financial position by more than £900m over nine years.
Six days ago I wrote that banks financing transfer receivables owed by City had stepped back, and called it the first market price of sanction risk. That was trade credit at the edge of the system. This is term debt at the top of the group. In one week, the refusal to lend has moved from the club’s suppliers of credit to its parent’s.
- Size. $2bn is about £1.52bn at the exchange rate Reuters used (calculated). That is roughly 1.7 times CFG’s FY25 group revenue of £888.0m, and about 26% of the £5.9bn valuation implied by CFG’s own recent share issues (calculated).
- Purpose. Per the FT, the loan would have added liquidity to the group and refinanced existing credit facilities.
- Trigger. Not CFG’s cash flows, but a conduct finding. A lender has treated reputational and legal risk as a reason not to lend at any price.
- The paradox. Just over three weeks before this story, Apollo agreed to take a minority stake in Mubadala Capital, the asset management arm of the Abu Dhabi sovereign fund chaired by Sheikh Mansour and run by Khaldoon Al Mubarak, who also chairs CFG. Apollo will invest alongside the owner’s state. It will not lend to the owner’s football group.
- The owner filled the gap. Within a month of the findings, Sheikh Mansour’s Newton Investment and Development put £100m of new equity into CFG. Football’s lender of last resort is, again, the shareholder.
- The banking parallel. In 2007 the first sign of distress was not a default but counterparties declining to roll funding. Football is now seeing the same sequence: withdrawal by credit providers before any regulator has acted, and before any sanction is set.
What the Financial Times has reported
The FT’s account, as relayed by Reuters and Investing.com, is specific on the deal and the trigger, and silent on the people and the vehicle.
| Point | What the FT reported |
|---|---|
| Lender | Apollo Global Management, the New York alternative asset manager (over $1tn of assets under management) |
| Borrower | City Football Group, parent of Manchester City and clubs in Europe, the Americas and Asia |
| Amount | $2bn |
| Stage | Final negotiations; talks ended after the September ruling |
| Purpose | Additional liquidity for CFG and refinancing of existing credit facilities |
| Trigger | The independent Commission’s finding that City used sham commercial contracts to inflate revenue and understate costs by more than £900m over nearly a decade |
| Owner response | Sheikh Mansour injected £100m of equity into CFG through Newton Investment and Development in the month after the findings (Companies House) |
| Club position | Denies wrongdoing; will appeal, calling the Commission’s opinion unsafe and citing factual and legal errors. The appeal is reportedly due next month; if it fails, sanctions are likely next year |
| Apollo’s wider sport book (per the FT) | Majority owner of Atlético de Madrid; £80m loan to Nottingham Forest (December 2024); $2.6bn financing for the New York Yankees’ holding company (August) |
| Comment | Reuters could not independently verify the report; Apollo and City had not responded out of hours |
The finding itself was handed down on 29 September 2026: guilty on 114 of the 115 charges. No sanction has been set.
The word that matters in the FT’s account is final. Apollo did not decline at the first meeting. It ran the credit work, negotiated terms, and stopped. That is the profile of a lender whose view of the borrower’s cash flows did not change but whose risk appetite did.
Who made the decision: what is known and what is not
The FT does not name the individuals who ended the talks, the Apollo vehicle that would have lent, or CFG’s negotiating team. I will not fill that gap with guesswork. What can be set out is the accountable structure on each side, from public sources.
On Apollo’s side. Apollo’s dedicated sports business is Apollo Sports Capital (ASC), launched on 29 September 2025 as a permanent capital holding company investing mainly in credit and hybrid capital across sport.
| Role | Person |
|---|---|
| Chief executive, ASC | Al Tylis (former NorthStar Asset Management CEO; owner and chairman of Club Necaxa and La Equidad) |
| Co-portfolio managers, ASC | Rob Givone and Lee Solomon, Apollo partners (Givone was co-chief credit officer) |
| Chief strategy officer, ASC | Sam Porter |
| Sponsor executive | John Zito, co-president of Apollo Asset Management, who launched ASC and fronted Apollo’s Mubadala Capital deal |
| Group chief executive | Marc Rowan |
ASC is the natural home for a sports credit of this kind. But ASC’s assets under management were about $7bn at Q3 2026, and its football book about $1.2bn at cost, almost all Atlético. A $2bn single-name loan would have been around 29% of ASC’s AUM and more than one and a half times its entire football exposure (calculated). A ticket that size would ordinarily be shared across Apollo’s wider credit platform or syndicated. It would also, almost certainly, have gone to Apollo’s senior credit and risk committees rather than being an ASC decision alone. That is an inference from scale and standard practice, not a reported fact.
On CFG’s side. CFG’s chairman is Khaldoon Al Mubarak, who is also Managing Director and Group CEO of Mubadala and Chairman of Abu Dhabi’s Executive Affairs Authority. The person with significant control is Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed, UAE Vice President and chairman of Mubadala. My September board-mapping found that four of Manchester City’s six directors hold current roles in the Abu Dhabi state or its enterprises. CFG’s chief executive is Ferran Soriano, in post since 2012; its group COO, Roel de Vries, left in May 2026, mid-way through the period in which this financing was being built.
The decision that is on record is the owner’s response, not the lender’s. Within a month of the findings, Newton subscribed for 11,327,163 new CFG shares for about £100m, described by CFG as equity from its largest shareholder. Whether a sovereign or parent guarantee was offered to keep Apollo at the table, and refused, is not known. It is the most important unanswered question in this story.
Where the money would have come from
The FT does not say which Apollo pool would have funded the loan. Apollo’s public disclosures show where its lending capital comes from, and every one of these sources has a reason to be cautious about a borrower under a conduct finding.
| Capital source | What it is | Why a City exposure is awkward for it |
|---|---|---|
| Apollo Sports Capital | Permanent capital vehicle; about $7bn AUM (Apollo 3Q 2026 8-K) | Concentration: $2bn is too large a share of one young vehicle |
| Athene | Apollo’s retirement services and annuity insurer; long-dated liabilities matched against private credit, enlarged by the 2025 acquisition of Pension Insurance Corporation | Insurance capital is watched by regulators and rating agencies; a loan to a borrower found to have used sham contracts carries headline and capital-treatment risk |
| Apollo credit funds and wealth vehicles | Institutional credit funds, Apollo Debt Solutions BDC, and semi-liquid European vehicles such as the AEPC ELTIF | Retail and semi-liquid investors redeem on headlines; a contested, sanction-exposed name is hard to hold and harder to mark |
| Syndication | Sale of portions to other lenders | A refused credit at Apollo is harder to place elsewhere |
This is the point my private credit work has made since 2025. Private credit is not a separate pool of patient money. It is insurance balance sheets, pension commitments and wealth-channel savings, packaged through managers who answer to their own regulators and investors. When the manager asks whether it wants a name on its books, the question includes how that name looks to an annuity holder, a rating agency and a wealth client. For CFG in November 2026, the answer was no.
The Abu Dhabi paradox
Apollo has not walked away from Abu Dhabi. It has walked away from Abu Dhabi’s football group, while moving closer to Abu Dhabi itself.
| Date | Apollo and the Abu Dhabi principals |
|---|---|
| 2020 | Mubadala anchors Apollo Strategic Origination Partners |
| Sep 2023 | Apollo invests in Mubadala Capital’s new evergreen Solutions strategy |
| Nov 2024 | Multi-year extension of the Apollo–Mubadala origination partnership |
| 26 Oct 2026 | Apollo agrees a minority stake in Mubadala Capital (nearly 10%, per CNBC); Apollo and other investors to commit $5bn to its strategies |
| By 19 Nov 2026 | Apollo has ended talks on a $2bn loan to CFG (FT) |
Mubadala Capital’s parent, Mubadala Investment Company, is chaired by Sheikh Mansour. Its Managing Director and Group CEO is Khaldoon Al Mubarak. The same two men sit at the top of CFG.
The lender is therefore drawing a clean line between the sovereign and the football asset. It will hold equity alongside the state. It will not take credit risk on the club group, even though the club group is owned by the same principal, chaired by the same executive, and has never been allowed to fail.
In banking language, Apollo is refusing to price implicit support. Before 2008, markets lent to bank-sponsored vehicles on the assumption that the sponsor would step in. After 2008, the Basel Committee wrote guidance on exactly this “step-in risk”, because the assumption proved unreliable. Apollo’s position is the post-crisis one: if the owner’s support is real, put it in the contract. Owner equity, a guarantee or collateral would count. A reputation for generosity does not.
That turns a question I raised last week into the central one. If Abu Dhabi’s support for CFG is unconditional, why has it not been made explicit to a lender that already trusts Abu Dhabi enough to buy into its asset manager?
Why CFG wanted the money
Manchester City is financially strong. CFG, the group around it, is not self-funding, and its debt has a maturity date. The figures below are from my CFG funding review.
- Losses. CFG’s pre-tax loss widened from £122.2m (FY24) to £292.3m (FY25). Manchester City produced £694.1m of the £888.0m group revenue and lost only £9.9m, which implies the rest of the group and central costs lost about £280m.
- Owner funding. About £650m of owner-side equity has gone in since mid-2024, at an unchanged implied price of about £8.83 a share (£5.9bn for the group). No outside investor has put in primary equity since Silver Lake’s $500m in 2019.
- Debt to refinance. The $650m seven-year term loan arranged in July 2021 (underwritten by Barclays, with HSBC and KKR Capital Markets) falls due in July 2028, alongside a £100m revolving facility from the same group. Separately, Etihad Park in New York carries non-recourse, stadium-secured construction finance.
- Transfer payables. Manchester City’s gross transfer payables were £423.0m at 30 June 2025, up 84%, before a summer 2026 spend Bloomberg put at about £450m across nine players.
| CFG equity issue (since 2024) | Amount | Subscriber |
|---|---|---|
| 14 Oct 2026 | ~£100m (11,327,163 shares) | Newton, confirmed by CFG |
| 31 Oct 2025 | ~£60m | Owners (Newton implied) |
| 14 Mar 2025 | ~£70m | Owners (Newton implied) |
| 1 Nov 2024 | £210m | Newton (attributed) |
| 30 Jun 2024 | £210m | Newton (attributed) |
Read against that, a $2bn facility was not opportunistic. It would likely have refinanced the 2021 bank debt well ahead of its 2028 maturity (the FT says only “existing credit facilities”), termed out liquidity for a loss-making group, and reduced the need for repeated owner subscriptions. Its failure leaves CFG with three routes: a smaller or more expensive deal elsewhere, more owner equity, or an explicit Abu Dhabi credit enhancement. The October £100m suggests the second route has already started.
How this fits the banking crisis analogies
My systemic risk series for the IFR (IFR/SOTG/SR/2025/01 and the reports that followed) modelled football on the banking system before 2008: thin capital, heavy reliance on short-term and wholesale-style funding, opaque exposures between institutions, and supervisors who learn of stress after the market does. The Apollo decision fits that model closely.
| Banking crisis, 2007–12 | Football, November 2026 |
|---|---|
| Wholesale lenders stop rolling funding before any regulator acts (Northern Rock, August–September 2007) | Transfer-receivable banks (Bloomberg, 13 Nov) and Apollo (FT, 19 Nov) withdraw before any sanction is set |
| “Not liquidity, solvency” (Gordon Brown, 2008) | City can pay; lenders doubt the durability of its value and owner support |
| Stress moves from money markets to interbank to bank equity | Stress moves from club trade credit to group term debt |
| Few dominant funders; when they retreat there is no market | Two private credit houses dominate big football tickets; one is impaired, the other has said no |
| Conduct findings (LIBOR, mis-selling) raise funding costs and cut counterparty appetite | A finding of sham contracts closes a $2bn credit line |
| Step-in risk: implicit sponsor support stops being assumed | Apollo will not price Abu Dhabi’s implicit support for CFG |
| State recapitalisation of banks | Newton’s £100m into CFG within a month |
| Sovereign–bank “doom loop” (euro area, 2010–12) | CFG’s credit becomes a function of one sovereign owner’s willingness to pay |
Implication one: the market has moved before the regulator
In 2007 the first evidence of distress was counterparties refusing to roll funding. Supervisors acted afterwards. Here, two separate lenders in two separate markets have withdrawn within a week. The appeal has not been heard and no sanction exists. The market is pricing an outcome the regulatory process has not yet produced.
Implication two: a liquidity symptom with a solvency cause
Gordon Brown’s 2008 diagnosis was that what looked like a liquidity squeeze was a solvency problem. CFG does not lack cash; it lacks a lender willing to bet that its value survives a sanction intact. The refusal is a judgment on the group’s capital, not its bank balance. That is the case my solvency paper makes for football as a whole: the system is undercapitalised, and liquidity is only as good as the solvency behind it.
Implication three: contagion is climbing the capital structure
Week one hit the cheapest, shortest credit: receivables owed by City to selling clubs. Week two hit the largest, longest credit: group term debt. The next layers are visible: the 2028 term loan maturity, the expected bond refinancing of Etihad Park, and sponsor contracts now read in the light of the sham-contract finding.
Implication four: funding concentration is the weak point
I have described football’s big-ticket lending as an Ares–Apollo duopoly. Ares is absorbing losses on Eagle Football, where administrators put its claim above $547m, and remains exposed to Chelsea’s holding companies. Apollo has now declined CFG, the best-resourced owner group in the Premier League. In receivables, five lenders account for about 93.6% of activity. When the dominant funders step back, there may be no market at all, only the owner.
Implication five: conduct risk has become credit risk
After 2008, conduct findings against banks changed who would deal with them and at what price. The City finding goes further, because it goes to the reliability of the accounts. A lender’s leverage and interest-cover tests run off reported revenue and costs. If the Commission says those figures were inflated for nine years, the lender’s starting numbers are in question. Reputational risk and credit risk become the same risk.
Implication six: the owner is the lender of last resort
Newton’s £100m is football’s version of bank recapitalisation. Equity is the right medicine: it absorbs losses, debt does not. But it ties CFG’s credit to a single sovereign’s continued willingness to fund. The euro area learned in 2010–12 that a bank whose standing rests on its sovereign is only as strong as that link. CFG’s link is strong, but it is discretionary, not contractual.
Implication seven: the maturity wall now sits inside the sanction window
My PE maturity risk report warned that football’s refinancing dates cluster, and that refinancing in stress is where solvency is tested. CFG’s 2021 term loan matures in July 2028. Sanctions are expected in 2027. Unless the debt is refinanced first, CFG will negotiate it while under penalty.
Implication eight: the prime name has been re-tiered
Elite-club receivables had compressed to margins of about 1.5%. Football credit was pricing the top clubs as near risk-free. In a week, the strongest name in the league has gone from the cheapest tier to one at least two lenders will not price. That is what repricing looks like before a crisis: not a gradual widening, but a sudden absence of bids.
The counter-case
The strongest reply is that none of this threatens City’s ability to pay, and that is correct.
- The owner has never failed to fund. £650m in 28 months, £100m within weeks of the finding. Abu Dhabi’s capacity is not in doubt.
- Manchester City’s own balance sheet is strong. Net assets above £850m at 30 June 2025, and the club itself carries little external debt.
- Apollo’s decision may be about Apollo. A listed manager raising money from insurers and wealth clients has its own headline risk. Stepping back during an appeal is a cheap, reversible choice, and it may return once the outcome is known.
- Other lenders exist. CFG’s 2021 banks, Gulf banks and US money-centre banks could all write a smaller or secured facility.
- Single-sourced reporting. The FT’s account rests on unnamed people; Reuters could not verify it, and neither party has commented.
The systemic point survives all five. Systemic risk is not about whether the strongest institution survives. It is about what happens to the market when the strongest institution cannot borrow on normal terms. If CFG can be refused, any club can. The clubs without a sovereign behind them are the ones that will feel it.
What the regulator and the Premier League could do now
1. Treat a failed or withdrawn financing as a reportable event. Banks must tell supervisors about material funding stress. A club group that loses a material facility at final stage should notify the Independent Football Regulator, with the reason given by the lender.
2. Ask for explicit owner support where implicit support is being relied on. Where a group’s financial plan assumes owner funding, the regulator should be able to require it in contractual form: a guarantee, an equity commitment letter or escrowed funds. That is the step-in risk lesson applied to football.
3. Collateralise City’s outstanding transfer instalments until sanctions are final. As I proposed last week, an escrow, parent guarantee or letter of credit would make City paper financeable again and keep the risk with the party found in breach.
4. Stress-test refinancing under sanction. CFG’s 2028 maturity should be modelled against each sanction outcome, from a fine to relegation. Every club with a maturity inside 2027–28 should face the same test.
5. Map private credit concentration. The regulator should know, club by club, how much funding depends on Ares, Apollo and the main receivables banks, and what happens if any one of them stops.
6. Make a conduct finding a stress trigger. A finding that goes to the reliability of a club’s accounts should start an immediate liquidity and funding review, without waiting for the sanction.
What to watch
- The appeal hearing, reportedly next month, and its timetable for sanctions.
- Any replacement lender for CFG: who, how much, at what price, and with what security. New charges at Companies House will show it.
- Further Newton subscriptions, and whether Silver Lake participates or stays out.
- CFG’s FY26 accounts (year to 30 June 2026): borrowings, cash, going-concern language and any disclosed financing.
- Whether Apollo’s or Ares’s other football credits are re-marked or repriced.
- Further withdrawals from City-linked transfer receivables, and whether selling clubs start to demand cash up front.
Caveats and data limitations
- Lender identity. The FT names Apollo Global Management. Ares Management, the other large football lender, is not named in the FT’s report.
- Single source. The loan negotiation is reported by the FT alone, citing unnamed people. Reuters could not verify it. Apollo and City had not commented at the time of writing.
- No named decision-makers. The individuals who ended the talks, the Apollo vehicle, the loan terms, security and pricing are not reported. Leadership tables show accountable structures, not who decided.
- Calculated figures. The sterling equivalent of $2bn (at $1 = £0.7614), the ratios to revenue and implied valuation, and the share of ASC’s AUM are my calculations.
- Unverified CFG data. CFG’s group net debt, cash and current term-loan balance at 30 June 2025 have not been verified from primary accounts. Equity issues before October 2026 are attributed to Newton by press reports, not confirmed by CFG.
- Timing. The date Apollo ended talks is not reported; the Mubadala Capital stake was announced on 26 October 2026.
Sources
- Financial Times, Apollo scraps planned $2bn loan to Man City owner after rule breaches, 19 November 2026 (primary source for the loan story)
- Reuters, via Boursorama, 19 November 2026
- Investing.com, 19 November 2026
- Apollo: launch of Apollo Sports Capital, 29 September 2025
- Semafor: Apollo takes stake in Abu Dhabi’s Mubadala Capital, 26 October 2026
- MEED: Apollo takes stake in Mubadala Capital
- WAM: Mansour bin Zayed chairs Mubadala Investment Company board meeting, 10 February 2026
- Bloomberg: Ares owed $547 million after collapse of Textor’s Eagle Football, 3 June 2026
- The Esk: ‘When the lenders blink: Manchester City, transfer finance and the first market price of sanction risk (credit Bloomberg)’, 13 November 2026
- The Esk: ‘City Football Group: a funding review, 2013 to October 2026’, 27 October 2026
- The Esk: ‘Apollo Sports Capital’s $7bn, broken down’, 4 November 2026
- The Esk: ‘Apollo’s minority stake in Mubadala Capital’, 28 October 2026
- The Esk: ‘Apollo Global Management’s exposure to European football and private credit financing’, April 2026
- The Esk: ‘Manchester City FC and City Football Group board relationship mapping’, 29 September 2026
- The Esk: ‘Solvency, not liquidity? Gordon Brown’s diagnosis of the 2008 banking crisis’, 6 October 2026
Cite this article
OSCOLA: Paul Quinn, ‘Apollo walks away: a $2bn “no” to City Football Group and football’s interbank moment’ (The Esk, 19 November 2026)
Harvard: Quinn, P. (2026) Apollo walks away: a $2bn ‘no’ to City Football Group and football’s interbank moment. The Esk, 19 November.
Case hub: Premier League v Manchester City · Dossiers: Apollo · City Football Group / Abu Dhabi · Ares Management
Leave a Reply